It is often relayed in race relation circles that the best way to overcome racism is to oversee the differences of race and simply look at people for who they are. As Dr. Martin Luther King said, judge individuals by the content of their character, not by the color of their skin. That is all great in principle; however generally, people do not have such discipline. So often we assess people based on what they look like, and once you go there, you can’t backtrack and defend statements without re-connecting it to race.
As much as I would like to talk about all the great people that live on Allied Drive and all the potential that residents here hold on their own, it is nearly impossible to talk about (and often defend) Allied Drive without addressing Madison’s divides relating to race.
I wish the following people didn’t go there:
"For the person shocked at the racial divide in this city all I want to say is that the white community has been bending over backwards to help black people. We are building them community centers, giving them their own personal community police station, giving them practically free housing and intregrating them into our neighborhoods, promoting equal opportunity at the expense of more qualified white candidates etc..etc..etc..etc... And the black community is showing their appreciation for our generosity by filling up the local jails, making the entire city unsafe, ruining the public school system so badly that parents are taking their children to the suburbs or sending them to private schools and putting enormous pressure on the hard working tax payer. Twenty or thiry years ago, at least we were rewarded with a few good comedians, good barabues and some quality music from black people, but we don't even get that from them anymore. The black community now takes much more than they return. I think most native Madisonians would have perferred if they just stayed in Milwaukee or Chicago instead of moving to Madison and bringing the ghetto here with them."
"It's the black people who are causing the problems. they are predisposed to violence. get rid of the black people, and you will get rid of the crime. there is no disputing this."
"I also lived on Allied Drive circa 1967 and it was a perfectly safe neighborhood. Even back in 1967 it was one of the poorer parts of the city, but there was absolutely NO CRIME. The only difference between then and now is the demographics of the neighborhood. Back in 1967 it was all white and now it is all black. I find it quite interesting that many people blame crime on poverty, but back in 1967 none of the poor whites were causing a problem."
Source for all above comments: Channel 3000 Forums
These sorts of comments are endless. For me, the icing on the cake is when a reputed newspaper publishes editorials that defend such ignorance, as the Fitchburg Star published the words of Kurt Getknecht:
"Fitchburg's no leader in the struggle for racial equality, but it's probably no worse than most areas of the country. We're a heavily segregated community, mostly by economic status and class, which is also characteristic of much of the country, including Madison. It was mighty galling it was to listen to Lorri Wendorf's discourse on how Fitchburg residents should embrace differences, which assumed that their concerns about traffic weren't valid. Mind you, I'm not a huge defender of all things Fitchburg, but I felt surprisingly defensive of our fair city. It's difficult to fathom how funneling more traffic through a neighborhood fosters understanding and racial equality, but I probably don't understand the lofty precepts of Madison's elite. Pity the poor Fitchburg resident who had a car end up in his bedroom, a few feet from his bed. He's probably confused to learn that his attempt to prevent this from happening again is a reflection of bias."
Racism is a form of abuse and as with any other abuse, it is not up to the perpetrator to define when abuse is taking place. Furthermore, being "probably no worse than anyone else" is not a valid defense. If you are honestly thinking that you are "probably no worse than anyone else", maybe it is time to venture out and see how you really fare with the rest of the country, and maybe even the rest of the world.
Look at Madison's disproportionate rates of incarceration, home ownership and per-capita income, all among which Wisconsin and Dane County lead in racial disparities when compared to other states and counties in the US. For three years of my life, I had a job that required travel for 120 days out of the year through which I have repeatedly visited nearly every major city in the United States and I can say hands down, I have never felt the levels of unspoken discomfort about race until I came to Madison.
Allied Drive is the most disconnected area of the city when you look at bus routes and accessibility, and we have to actually fight to open up a street? I’ve sat in and observed a lot of meetings about Allied Drive and I remember hearing Fitchburg residents say that they do not want the people of Allied Drive walking up and down the streets of their community, so to back track and shift the focus to traffic safety is like listening to a rapist blame short skirts. You have got to be kidding me.
I have not written in my blog for some time because it has to be known that these issues are very tolling. It is similar to being in a difficult relationship. Sometimes you come to the conclusion that your partner is not going to change so futile efforts may be better spent toward something more constructive. Like a condo downtown. In a city that embraces differences, away from all this madness.
30 comments:
It's the pervasive "us against them" attitude in Madison that I think is odd. You can see it in the comments you quote above. Inherent in that mentality is the idea that the "us" belongs, and the "them" don't. But, because Madison is so "liberal" and "enlightened", the "them" are tolerated and condescended to, but never fully embraced as equals or peers. I think that's just because it's been so overwhelmingly white here for as long as Madison has existed. Change comes slowly, acceptance of change comes even more slowly. I wish I could say that patience is all that we need, but the backlash against civil rights in this country over the last year or two has made me quite cynical about the ability of a place like Madison to ever fully integrate into the United States.
Fitchburg needs to understand that aint got shit to do with us that they misplaced all their roads. That road that caused dude to crash into a bedroom would not be safe at 20mph with its lighting and all the twists and turns, you can't see shit at night out there. On top of that you have parking on two sides of the street leaving not enough room already for two cars to be on the bitch. and then you going to let parking be on both sides with all it's blind spots. That does not have shit to do with Allied. I guess this guy thinks that niggas and hip hop are responsible for pit bull fighting too even though honkies have been doing it for years.
I can't imagine why residents of a suburb would want to be isolated against Chicago's violent rejects. I mean, when someone empties a clip at some dude in the street, that just means that we need more compassion and outreach, not that we need to put his ass in jail or something.
Really, though, it's racism since most of the colored folks on Allied are good people and aren't related to the violent crime that the area is known for.
Wow Robert - I think I understand your type ... you think that all black people play basketball, all Indian people own gas stations, all Mexican people love tacos and all white people are good, tax paying citizens whose hard work built the wealth of this country. This logic makes my point precisely.
Truely said that individuals should be judge by the content of their character and not by the color of their skin. But the real thing is that we need to have patience.
From what I read here, I feel reassured. I´m from germany and got called a nazi numerous times from guys from the so-called allied forces. I´m no nazi, not even pure-strain german. As sad as it is, my advice is to clean your own backyard, before talking bad about other countries.
Hi
No, I don't think so that any evil in the city is for black, Although it is true most the criminal is black, but there is a lot of reason behind that like black are not so wealth like white.
The article gives more varied results.
The article gives more confinemnet.
I wonder in which part of Madison does Ms Trivedi live? I invite her to come live in the Meadowood Park area, now invaded by African-Americans. I invite her to check out the men/youths hanging around in the parking lots at all times of the day: spitting, urinating, brawling, trespassing, testing the loudness of each other's car stereos, and picking on passersby. If such a situation does not elicit strong race emotions I do not know what does. I know a lot of good folks who are moving out of the area this summer. Mixed-income neighborhoods SHOULD BE BANNED!
I recently came across your blog and found this interesting post. I totally agree with Carrey that individuals should be judge by the content of their character and not by the color of their skin.
It's so easy to blame crime and other social problems on race. It glosses over, what is, an extremely complicated issue.
To say that the problem is race because, 50 years ago this place was poor and all white but had no crime, is ridiculous.
People do not want to live in discipline.Cause they think that its a joy if we able to break the discipline behind law.
I didn't realize madison wisc is so backwards. I thought americans were more in tune with civil liberties and I am very surprised by the attitudes you quoted in your article. I guess it proves that ignorant people can be anywhere even where you least expect.
"allied resident" thinks that it is twists and turns of Allied Drive that caused someone to crash into a bedroom? It was my duplex that had a car driven into it at 5AM, about 6 or 7 years ago, unless there has been another car driving into a bedroom on Allied. And it had nothing to do with any "twists and turns". Some woman was trying to run over her boyfriend, from a parking lot across the street, and she backed across the street at 30 mph and ran into my renter's bedroom. You can't blame that on anyone but the silly woman who tried to kill her boyfriend using her friend's car.
Funny thing was, she applied to rent that same duplex from me just a few months before, but she was on Section 8, and tried to get her boyfriend to rent with her--which is against Section 8 rules.
Wait, it can't even be Allied that "allied resident" is talking about, because s/he mentioned "parking on both sides of the street. There is no street parking at allowed on Allied, for the entire street.
I too agree individuals should be judge by the content of their character and not by the color of their skin.
People always like freedom. So, it is not possible to do work under stream pressure. Thanks
To E.C. said...
Creativity is lovely. It's an embellishment that you earn after you can nourish and maintain your personal safety. You are not "safe" near Allied Drive. It's 80 degrees outside and your neighbors keep their windows closed tight.
I know! I'll be the individual who leaves my windows wide open! You can read about my demise in tomorrow's newspaper.
I am reading your post and thank you for sharing this post. I is full of nice knowledge. So keep it up
I think one should not believe in prejudices that are the great problem in the way of progress and a dispute hurdle between the developed and under developed countries.Man is known as the character which he has.So don't believe on race which is produced only for recognition.Thanks for sharing information.Good luck
It is not difficult to blame other. So it may be social problems on race.
It is very impressive post.
I do agree with you , people have their own identity, their casts, creed, color ,language do not make themselves. It is only the personal character that makes a man
I hope everyone understand it !
great article
Hello. This post is likeable, and your blog is very interesting, congratulations :-).THANX FOR MAKING SUCH A COOL BLOG, I REALLY LIKE YOUR WRITING STYLE , KEEP IT UP :-)
If you circulate a publication then you want to know what your readers think and how they interact with your printed Digital publication. Unfortunately, print surveys for these publications are costly, time consuming and very rarely are they a 100% sampling of your audience.
if people did follow MLK's classic "not by color" example, the world wouldn't be what it is today!
In terms of inequalities we can address race, but in terms of generalizations and evaluating people it's pointless to use race.
The idea of race relies on the belief that there are differences between skin colors. I refuse to accept this, asides from purely cosmetic differences related to melanin quantity, skin color or 'race' is a pointless evaluation.
To E.C. -
I think you were born today, or maybe you are just coming out. LOL. Go back in history and you will be surprised, no wait, actually you will be shocked, that the richest economies of the world were not from Europe (ouch) but they were from Asia - namely India and China. That's until your very advanced civilizations from Europe namely - the Dutch, the Portuguese, the French, the Spaniards and the worst of all the British started attacking India and looting India and killing and maiming and did I mention looting/robbing/plundering India.
On a side note I don't understand whats with this great European civilizations that believe so much in killing and looting other people's wealth instead of creating their own wealth. Where ever you advanced civilizations have gone, they have only robbed, looted and killed the locals - America (North and South), Africa, Asia, Australia, they have not spared anything. If this is advanced, I shudder to think what the uncivilized Europeans would be capable of. They would maybe put the present day Taliban to shame.
Man is man by the way he acts not race and it should stay that way
I really like you think everybody informational blogs, this type of information will have everyone even if they have opened. I would firstly like to congratulate the blog owner. We have completed our own issues with the missing. Thank you very much!
Post a Comment